Re: Tall or short?
Same difference! Logically it would seem that the more water, the more cooling effect, but of my large hookahs, medium size and minis, I see no difference. (That includes my large "Chiller") hookah when I used to waste time actually putting ice in it! I smoke the chiller and various other sized hookahs at the saame time and no difference in cool or not.
I have in the back of my mind to find a very large glass vase with a small mouth-opening and fitting some type of 2 sized grommet to it since otherwise my large hookah stems will wobble,but no illusions that it will smoke cooler, even a 2 quart or more! We'll see.