Re: Just opened my tin of SB Pumpkin Pie..
Yep, it can be soapy. I had a 100g like that, the next one tasted very weak and dry, and not much like pumpkin. The next one was almost a different tobacco altogether, very wet and no stringy stem pieces - this one smelled very heavily of spices and pie crust and I cold barely taste any pumpkin.
Fantasia's* is definitely better.