Originally Posted by Hajo Flettner
The 1-5 scale is all fine and well except that it doesn't say why exactly something is any given number or rate in any precise way how the reviewer weighs smoke quality/amount Vs. taste Vs. longevity Vs. smell or the overall value of the product. Take at look at my reviews and let me know what you think of the approach when you have a few minutes.
I agree. Keep in mind I'm using the 1-5 scale strictly for video reviews and as such can freely talk about what ever pertinent points I feel are necessary. In the past I never bothered giving a number at all so the 1-5 is just a way to sort of sum up the review.
I do like your format for written reviews. I'm curious though about the max number of points for each category. Is it a max of 50 for each?
EDIT: NEVER MIND I FIGURED IT OUT!!